using PEN's evidence-analysis approach
Every day, nutrition is in the news, touting the miraculous nature of a food, blaming a food or food group for all that ails us, or espousing a diet that promises to cure all our woes. PEN, as part of its media and journal monitoring, has noted examples of where article headlines may be sensationalized and does not always reflect the study in question and what was actually published in the article. We are not the only ones who have noticed this issue. A recent article by Yavchitz and colleagues found that 40% of RCTs are reported in a way that emphasizes the beneficial effect of the experimental treatment, thereby distorting the actual results.
PEN has published our comments and evidence analyses on
PEN’s News-Making Evidence, as a
PEN Facebook note and in previous PEN eNews articles. We have published on topics such as egg yolks and cardiovascular disease risk,
pass the salt or pass on the salt,
Do Cancers Crave Carbs, red meat consumption and mortality, and infant antibiotics use and subsequent development of obesity. Through our social media monitoring, we have also noted examples of dietitians publishing their own critical thoughts on trending nutrition topics, including the questionable benefits of going gluten-free for weight loss, arsenic and rice, and an analysis of the popular book Wheat Belly, to name only a few.
Dietitians are evidence-based health professionals and can help cut through the nutrition clutter, helping to separate fact from fiction. Through our foundational knowledge and on-going consumption of newly published literature, dietitians help to shed light on perspectives that may have been missed and help to contextualize the findings to the bigger picture. If you have a critical appraisal on a nutrition-related topic that is making news that you want to share, please email us at
eNews@pennutrition.com.
This edition of PEN eNews 2(3) has many resources to help you create evidence-analyses. What’s the Buzz About Open Access explores the benefits and downfalls of open access journals. We highlight the issues around publication bias, an important perspective to consider during critical appraisal. We have several articles describing how dietitians are using PEN, including PEN in Action: Using PEN to Update Consumer Resources. As part of our six-part series to help you foray into social media with confidence, we share Social Media Tip #3. We highlight a guide that describes how PEN can be used for nutrition student assignments. As a preview to eNews 2(4), PEN at Work describes the reaction to PEN at the recent International Congress of Dietetics.
This and more in eNews 2(3).
Kristyn Hall MSc, RD
Editor, PEN eNews
PEN eNews may contain links to other external websites. Pennutrition.com is not responsible for the privacy practices or the content of such external websites. Dietitians of Canada does not endorse the content, products or services on other websites.